top of page

Representative Mike Bost Will Not Support a Moratorium | Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Dear Representative Bost,

Thank you for meeting with me today and agreeing to take a look at the Illinois EPA Brine Field Assessment I delivered to you this morning. I felt the need to at least address with you the industry’s lie that there has been “no documented contamination” from fracking in Illinois.

I am of course still reflecting upon your position to pursue regulation, without support for a moratorium on fracking.

Naturally, I am reflecting also that regulation was not able to prevent the contamination named in the Brine Report I provided you today, unable to prevent it in 1997, and unable to prevent it today among the local folks I mentioned to you here in Southern Illinois (who are currently being affected by oil field waste water disposal wells in White and other counties).

My question remains unanswered:  if regulation hasn’t been working to protect Illinoisans in the past and present, because of lack of funds and personnel, how can regulations protect us in the future?

Illinois farmer Mr. Dart says in this article that  there are supposed to be rules and regulations that prevent contamination like this from happening. But we are hearing again and again, there is simply not enough money or personnel to enforce or monitor those regulations. To boot, some contamination issues cannot be fixed by regulation (such as the radioactivity of our Shale, and the volumes of radioactive waste water that cannot be returned to the hydrologic cycle).  You must admit, it is a rather irresponsible duo: regulation with little or no enforcement or monitoring?

It is neither extreme nor radical to want to understand the truth of what is happening. And once we uncover that truth, as the public servants we agreed we are, it is our moral obligation not to sweep those truths under the rug. Two additional attached reports* let me know that the industry is not being truthful to the people affected most: those living in the areas of oil and gas industry activity. If the truth spells a very dirty and toxic future with high volume-horizontal fracking, then we have a right to speak up about that truth and fight to protect each other and our water and land.

The legacy we continue to allow to be left upon this good land saddens and troubles me deeply.

Lynn Waters 512 N. Springer Carbondale, IL 62901 (618) 351-1016

* The two additional reports sent via email to Representative Bost were Cracks in the Facade and Drilling Double Speak

Oil Pollution a Bitter Harvest for Illinois Farmers

Environment: State has more than 4,000 abandoned wells, many of whose leaks have harmed soil, water supplies.

(Lynn Waters spoke with Mr. Marc Ayers of Lt. Governor Sheila Simon’s office regarding this figure and he corrected her: there are not 4,000 abandoned oil wells in Illinois, there are over 6,000).

January 22, 1997 OBLONG, Ill. — Laird Dart stops his pickup in the middle of a huge patch of bare ground in a cornfield.

“This is all sterile,” he says with a sweep of his hand across the patch, which runs 660 feet long and 18 feet wide. “Nothing will grow here. You can’t keep it from washing away.”

The culprit: a long-abandoned oil well whose rusty pipes are leaking salt water into the soil Dart farms. A soil conservation expert once estimated 900 tons of dirt had washed away from the patch, he says.

Several hundred yards away, the earthy smell of crude oil oozes through the air next to a cluster of rusty oil storage and separation tanks. Some of the tanks, in a low wooden shed, have been leaking. A reddish-black goo interspersed with deep puddles of brackish water covers the ground, spilling over a tiny berm into the cornfield beyond.

“There’s rules and regulations that’s supposed to keep this from happening,” Dart says in disgust.

But those rules are weak and too often ignored, Southern Illinois farmers like Dart say. Like several other southeastern Illinois counties, Crawford County is dotted with abandoned, leaking oil wells, the legacy of what one official calls the industry’s “past sins.”

Illinois has more than 4,000 abandoned oil wells, and it’s the state’s job to plug them. With a $500,000 budget, the most the state can afford is capping 75 to 100 wells per year. At the present pace, it will be decades before all the wells are plugged.

“There’s only so much money to go around,” said Neda Banach, a legislative liaison for the Illinois Department of Natural Resources. “Because of the sheer number of wells involved, it’s not something we can do in a year’s time or two years’ time.”

The problems are getting worse. Oil wells leak salt water because Illinois crude is mixed with salt water to begin with–usually more salt water than oil.

Most oil producers take the leftover salt water from their wells and pump it back into the ground to put pressure on the remaining oil, making it easier to pump out of the well. But pressurizing the underground system also can force oil and salt water out of abandoned wells that tap the same system.

The underground water many people use for drinking supplies is above the oil zone, and leaking oil wells can contaminate this water as well.

In the Crawford County hamlet of Hardinville, for example, residents pay up to $50 per month for treated water because oil and brine have contaminated many wells.

“Most of the people around here get city water, even though it’s expensive,” said Bill Rosborough, a farmer and real estate broker living in Hardinville.

Dart and Rosborough belong to a group of farmers seeking a solution. Their work is complicated, they said, by politics and economics. Much of the blame lies in lax state regulations and poor environmental practices by oil companies, said Lelan Russell, executive vice president of the Illinois Oil and Gas Association.

Until recently, the state required oil drillers to sign a bond agreeing to cap their wells when they were finished pumping. When operators of thousands of wells went out of business or sold off their wells during the 1980s, many merely forfeited those bonds to the state.

That left the state with debts that are difficult to collect and the job of capping wells dating back to 1900, Russell said.

Now, oil producers pay a fee to the state to fund the abandoned wells program. Oil producers plan to lobby for more state funding of the program and may ask for federal help to clean up the leaking wells, Russell said.

“We have to figure out how to deal with our past sins,” he said. “The state didn’t realize they were going to inherit all of these thousands of wells when the bonds were forfeited.”

Another part of the problem, the farmers said, is that big oil companies sold their Illinois wells more than a decade ago, when oil prices plunged. That left a legion of smaller companies, many financially unstable, with the job of operating the wells and capping them properly.

Since oil prices were so low, the smaller operators had a tough time turning enough of a profit to pay for the cleanup of leaking wells. When those small companies go belly-up, the state must foot the cleanup bill.

The farmers’ group has backed a plan to form a state task force on the abandoned wells issue.

But the plan is stalled. The state Department of Natural Resources refuses to name members to such a panel, saying the Department of Mines and Minerals is plugging the wells. Democratic state Rep. Charles Hartke, sponsor of the task force plan, said it is needed to find new sources of revenue to expand well-plugging activities.

The farmers said they will not give up until the problem is solved.

“We don’t want to see this mess left to the next generation,” Dart said.


Recent Posts

See All

Bill that would have sped up fracking in Illinois dies,0,5572516.story By Julie Wernau Tribune staff reporter 11:37 a.m. CDT, May 28, 2014 A bill that s

Voice of the Reader: Yes, it’s frustrating May 16, 2014 1:00 am To the Editor: “Frustration is growing over


bottom of page